43 papers of a former CSIR scientist retracted

-



Papers of Ashok Pandey of CSIR-NIIST in Thiruvananthapuram and CSIR-IITR in Lucknow published in the journal Bioresources Technology, where he served as editor-in-chief, have been retracted

Forty-three papers of Ashok Pandey who retired from the Thiruvanthapuram-based National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science and Technology (CSIR-NIIST) and now associated with the Lucknow-based Indian Institute of Toxicology Research (CSIR-IITR) that were published in an Elsevier journal Bioresources Technology have been retracted. PubPeer, a website that allows researchers to discuss and review scientific research after publication, has listed all the 43 retracted papers.


As per a reliable source at CSIR-IITR lab, Dr. Pandey retired from CSIR-NIIST in 2015 and has been an industry-sponsored distinguished scientist at CSIR-IITR since 2018. His tenure as an industry-sponsored distinguished scientist was first renewed in 2020 and again in August 2023 for a period of three years subject to condition that his annual performance be assessed each year and renewed for the remaining period. The next annual performance review will be in August this year. Prior to CSIR-IITR, he was an industry-sponsored distinguished scientist at the Mohali-based DBT lab — Center of Innovative and Applied Bioprocessing (CIAB).


Dr. Pandey was made the editor-in-chief of the journal in 2011. Prior to this, Dr. Pandey served as the executive editor of the journal. While two retracted papers published in 2009 and 2010 were when Dr. Pandey was the executive editor, the remaining papers were published while he was the editor-in-chief of the journal.

Twenty-three papers that have been retracted were published when Dr. Pandey was working at CSIR-NIIST, while 13 retracted papers were published when Dr. Pandey has been associated with CSIR-IITR, and four retracted papers were published when he was with CIAB.

The reasons cited in most of the retraction notices published by the journal are that Dr. Pandey handled the review of the initial submission of the manuscript either in the capacity of the executive editor or the editor-in-chief and had required a revision of the manuscript. Dr. Pandey’s name was added as a coauthor when the revised version was submitted by the authors without any explanation. While in a couple of instances, the manuscript was assigned to a different editor before it was eventually accepted for publication, in four instances, Dr. Pandey was listed as an author on the original submission of the paper but his name was removed from the authorship list at some stage and hence the published paper does not contain his name. However, in all the four instances, he continued to handle the review process, eventually accepting the paper for publication.

But in the case of 35 published papers that are now retracted, Dr. Pandey was involved in the initial review and continued to handle the review process even after the revised version with his name added as a coauthor was submitted. “Review of the initial submission of this paper was handled by the then journal editor-in-chief (Ashok Pandey) and revision required. Upon submission of the revised version, the journal editor-in-chief was added as a co-author and the editor-in-chief continued to handle the review process, eventually accepting the paper for publication. This compromised the editorial process and breached the journal’s policies,” says the retraction notice in all the 35 papers.


“This article has been retracted at the request of Elsevier’s Research Integrity & Publishing Ethics team and an independent ethics advisor. A journal-wide investigation identified violations of the journal’s policies on authorship and conflict of interest related to the submission and review of this paper,” the retraction note says.

An editor-in-chief of a Springer journal tells The Hindu that a journal manager handles the editorial process, checks for plagiarism in the manuscript, and raises a flag in case of any conflict of interest such as a journal editor also being listed as a coauthor before assigning the manuscript to the editor-in-chief. “This is the general practice in all journals by all publishers,” he says. The retraction notice does not make any mention of the role and lapses of the journal manager and lays all the blame on Dr. Pandey, he says.

Website: International Research Scientist Awards

#Professor, #Lecturer, #Scientist, #Scholar, #Researcher, #Analyst, #Engineer, #Technician, #Coordinator, #Specialist, #Writer, #Assistant, #Associate, #Biologist, #Chemist, #Physicist, #Statistician, #DataScientist, #Consultant, #Coordinator, #ResearchScientist, #SeniorScientist, #JuniorScientist, #PostdoctoralResearcher, #LabTechnician, #ResearchCoordinator, #PrincipalInvestigator, #ClinicalResearchCoordinator, #GrantWriter, #R&DManager, #PolicyAnalyst, #TechnicalWriter, #MarketResearchAnalyst, #EnvironmentalScientist, #SocialScientist, #EconomicResearcher, #PublicHealthResearcher, #Anthropologist, #Ecologist


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The research ranks are faculty positions for those who are advancing science within a laboratory or research group at Yale School of Medicine.

-
Image
  The research ranks are faculty positions for those who are advancing science within a laboratory or research group at Yale School of Medicine. Overview Research rank faculty hold a PhD, MD, or equivalent degree. There are three categories of research ranks: Associate Research Scientist (ARS ) , Research Scientist (RS), and Senior Research Scientist (SRS), as detailed in the Yale Faculty Handbook. Teaching is not required for these ranks. Persons who are asked to undertake teaching should also be given a teaching appointment as a lecturer . In such circumstances, an appropriate portion of the salary may be paid from a teaching budget; however, for research appointees who are already employed full-time, the total compensation cannot be increased by payment for teaching. Research rank faculty conduct or oversee research as a skilled or advanced member of a research group, center, or core. Typically support for the position is derived from PI sponsor or research program and there ...
Read more

Researchers discover a surprising way to jump-start battery performance

-
Image
  Menlo Park, Calif. — A lithium-ion battery’s very first charge is more momentous than it sounds. It determines how well and how long the battery will work from then on – in particular, how many cycles of charging and discharging it can handle before deteriorating. In a study published today in Joule, researchers at the SLAC-Stanford Battery Center report that giving research this first charge at unusually high currents increased their average lifespan by 50% while decreasing the initial charging time from 10 hours to just 20 minutes. Just as important, the researchers were able to use scientific machine learning to pinpoint specific changes in the battery electrodes that account for this increase in lifespan and performance – invaluable insights for battery manufacturers looking to streamline their processes and improve their products. The study was carried out by a SLAC/Stanford team led by Professor Will Chueh in collaboration with researchers from the Toyota Research Institu...
Read more

Your Guide to Becoming a Successful Research Scientist 2024!

-
Image
  Becoming a research scientist is quite the dream role for many individuals passionate about discovering new things and pushing the boundaries of what is known. They’ve also become essential in advancing science, technology, and our understanding of the world. If you’re wondering, “How can I become a research scientist?”, this guide will explain what a research scientist does, how to become a research scientist, their importance, the skills required, the different types of research scientists, their average salary, career opportunities, and the future of this exciting field. What Does a Research Scientist Do? In summary, research scientists conduct experiments, analyze data, and develop new theories or products. Their work is often performed in laboratories through fieldwork and theoretical research. They specialize in specific study areas, mainly biology, chemistry, physics, environmental and climate, or social sciences. They design and conduct experiments, collect and analyze d...
Read more